Can integrated information theory explain consciousness. The theory presented here claims that consciousness has to do with the capacity to integrate information. Integrated information theory of consciousness the open mind. According to the theory, consciousness corresponds to the capacity of a system to integrate information. Iit stems from thought experiments that lead to phenomenological axioms existence, compositionality, information, integration, exclusion and corresponding ontological postulates. Phi quantifies integration, the extent to which information is interconnected into a unified whole rather than split into disconnected parts. One prominent theory of consciousness is the integrated information theory of consciousness, otherwise known as iit.
The conscious pilotdendritic synchrony moves through the brain to mediate consciousness. Pdf integrated information theory of consciousness. The informational mind and the information integration theory of consciousness 5 data, or information. Initially proposed by giulio tononi in 2004, it claims that consciousness is identical to a certain kind of information, the realization of which requires physical, not merely functional, integration, and which can be measured mathematically. Iit is a novel new theory of consciousness proposed by guilio tononi 18. Integrated information theory iit approaches the relationship between consciousness and its physical substrate by first identifying the fundamental properties of experience itself. Integrated information theory iit is a theoretical framework for understanding consciousness developed by dr. Readers react to a critique of a radical new theory of consciousness. A theory of consciousness giorgio marchetti university of urbino according to william james theory of mind 1890, our conscious mental life flows continuously like a stream in which the transition between the thought of one object and the thought of another. Some people think perhaps this theoretical mathematical endeavour should be shelved for now. But while iit is presented as a theory of integrated information, it could equally serve as a theory of how energetic processing is organized since the physical substrate of consciousness consists in the causally interrelated patterns of neural firing that are identical with the conscious experience. But we cant just do fact gathering experiments we need a theory to understand what weve seen, and the basics of integrated information theory do hold promise. The information content also depends on human conventions about symbols and their meanings.
Based on the postulates, it permits in principle to derive, for any particular system of elements in a state, whether it has consciousness, how much, and which. For instance, why is our consciousness generated by certain parts of our brain, such as the thalamocortica. It functions as a guiding framework for a great deal of research into the neural basis of consciousness and for. Integrated information theory iit offers an explanation for the nature and source of consciousness. According to the information integration theory, this is the reason why these systems, although computationally very sophisticated, contribute little to consciousness. Background research on information integration and consciousness is closely linked to. Iit appears to be gaining popularity, and tononi has recently teamed up with neuroscientist chistof koch to promote the theory 4,6. A theory of consciousness that is too exclusive or chauvinistic. There was even a very high profile piece in nature having just listened to hakwan laus talk on this available at this conference website i thought i would write down a couple of reactions like everyone else who is interested in consciousness, i have been. On the axiomatic foundations of the integrated information. If consciousness corresponds to information integration, then a physical system should be able to generate consciousness to the extent that it can rapidly enter any large number of available states information, yet it cannot be decomposed into a collection of causally independent subsystems.
An information integration theory of consciousness. Integrated information theory iit does so by starting from conscious experience itself via five phenomenological axioms of existence, composition, information, integration, and. The integrated information theory of consciousness issue. Integrated information theory iit is based on the ideas of giulio tononi. Integrated information theory starts from the essential properties of phenomenal experience, from which it derives the requirements for the physical substrate of consciousness. We intuit that rocks, trees and countries do not have consciousness.
Author summary integrated information theory iit approaches the relationship between consciousness and its physical substrate by first identifying the fundamental properties of experience itself. From these it derives five postulates about the properties required of physical mechanisms to support consciousness. In this paper, i consider whether iit is compatible with a particular kind of panpsychism, known as russellian panpsychism, which purports to avoid the main problems of both physicalism and dualism. Integrated information theory of consciousness hacker news.
Measuring information integration measuring information integration. It is also the reason why there is no conscious experience associated with hypothalamic and brainstem circuits that regulate important physiological variables, such as blood. This claim is motivated by two key phenomenological properties of consciousness. Is integrated information theory viable as a theory of.
This claim may not seem selfevident, perhaps because, being endowed with consciousness for most of our existence, we take it for granted. An information integration theory of consciousness mendeley. Integrated information theory of consciousness internet. The integrated information theory of consciousness has been garnering some attention lately. Consciousness and neuroscience consciousness as information integration. An information integration theory of consciousness core. Integrated information theory iit of consciousness says that information being processed is conscious if a mathematical quantity called. Integrated information theory iit attempts to identify the essential properties of consciousness axioms and, from there, infers the properties of physical systems that can account for it postulates. There seems to be an incredible leap of faith equating information integration with consciousness. Integrated information the integrated information theory iit of consciousness claims that, at the fundamental level, consciousness is integrated information, and that its quality is given by the informational relationships generated by a complex of elements tononi, 2004. He states that while their hypotheses lead to an allornothing response, the information integration theory of consciousness is one that allows a graded response. This article presents an updated account of integrated information theory of consciousness iit and some of its implications. Integration information theories posit that the integration of information is necessary andor sufficient for consciousness.
The information integration th eory and other neurobiological frameworks. This suggests that the informational mind is a hypothesis about the connection between information and consciousness, whereas tononis theory, which lacks an account of meaningful data, is not. This theory claims that consciousness corresponds to a systems capacity to integrate information, and proposes a way to measure such capacity. Masafumi oizumi, larissa albantakis and giulio tononi proposed an interesting mechanistic explanation of consciousness in their paper from the phenomenology to the mechanisms of consciousness. Informationbased theories of consciousness are circular. Integrated information theory iit does so by starting from conscious experience itself via five phenomenological axioms of existence, composition, information, integration, and exclusion.
Consciousness is defined as experience, comprising any experience, such as the experience of shapes, sounds, thoughts, emotions and the self. The information integration theory of consciousness. Iit then postulates that the physical substrate of consciousness must satisfy these very properties. In this paper, we focus on three of the most prominent information integration theories. Is the integrated information theory of consciousness. Iit defines a property of a system called integrated information.
This claim may not seem selfevident, perhaps because, being endowed with consciousness for most of our existence, we take it. Experimental research on consciousness is going well, so maybe we should all just focus on that. In neuroscience, the integrated information theory iit tononi 2004, 2008, 2011. Abstract in this opinion article, we discuss how integrated information theory accounts for several aspects of the relationship between consciousness and the brain. The first is understanding the conditions that determine to what extent a system has conscious experience. For instance, the meaning of each and every quale is subjective and revolves around what we associate with based on previous experiences. An information integration theory of consciousness article pdf available in bmc neuroscience 51. But, neither do the authors of the theory to any real level develop this.
A theory of consciousness that is too inclusive or liberal, would grant consciousness to systems that dont have consciousness. In this perspective, tononi and colleagues describe the integrated information theory of consciousness and how it. Wed like to understand how you use our websites in order to improve them. The last section of this paper addresses a number of philosophical and practical problems with the experimental testing of the link between data and information integration and consciousness. Uncovering the neural basis of consciousness is a major challenge to neuroscience. A proper understanding of cognitive functions cannot be achieved without an understanding of consciousness, both at the empirical and at the theoretical level. Responses to critique of integrated information theory. The integrated information theory iit is a leading scientific theory of consciousness, which implies a kind of panpsychism.
Consciousness as information integration the theory presented here claims that consciousness has to do with the capacity to integrate information. Integrated information theory is not a theory of consciousness. Consciousness, information integration, and the brain. Giulio tononi and collaborators at the wisconsin institute for sleep and consciousness at the university of wisconsinmadison.
A thalamic reticular networking model of consciousness a thalamic reticular networking model of consciousness. This theory, initially formulated by giulio tononi back in 2004 and which has undergone development ever since, posits that consciousness is ultimately dependent on the degree of information integration that is inherent in the. Consciousness and information integration springerlink. The information integration theory of consciousness is ontologically less parsimonious than neural theories of consciousness, because it postulates consciousness as a different kind of entity from those used in the rest of science compare chalmers, 1996. Such postulation would be justified if there were facts that could not be explained by. Consciousness is integrated information information reduction in uncertainty uncertainty formalised as information entropy shannon, 1948 integrated information information generated by a system over and above information generated by its parts taken separately. Tononi, albantakis, and oizumi 2014 is a new fundamental theory of consciousness which has proved to have significant explanatory and predictive power, and it. An information integration theory of consciousness pdf. Among them, the integrated information theory iit proposed by giulio tononi 2004, 2008 is gaining experimental results on the study of altered states of consciousness such as sleep massimini et al.
Information stored in hopfield neural networks is naturally errorcorrected, but 1011 neurons support only about 37 bits of integrated information. Integrated information theory starts from the essential properties of phenomenal. These claims stem from realizing that information and integration. From the phenomenology to the mechanisms of consciousness. In this approach, every causal mechanism capable of choosing among alternatives generates information, and. The integrated information theory iit is one of the most influential scientific theories of consciousness. This information must be based on the systems causal powers, not on symbolic conventions. Information integration theory iit, global workspace theory gwt, and attended intermediatelevel theory air. An information integration theory of consciousness bmc. In contrast, according to iit, the only kind of information that matters for consciousness is the information a system has about itself. Consciousness, information integration, and the brain rotman.
1413 775 166 52 771 448 1595 405 583 1377 1107 514 801 1386 301 1026 1227 722 1102 1356 1556 243 463 889 495 801 897 283 1247 574 218 41 775 982 1121 469 131 1414 883 1316